Homo sarcasmus - a new species of blog from Heath L. Buckmaster

20 Feb, 2009

American Idol 2009 – Building the Top 12

Posted by: heath In: American Idol| Television

AI is mixing things up a bit this year with a new method for building the Top 12.

In the past we’ve had weeks and weeks of Top12 guys/girls, Top 10 guys/girls, Top 8 guys/girls, you can see where I’m going with this. But not this year.

Out of the Top 36 were 3 groups created. Was that too Yoda of me?

First Group Results: Anyway, the first grouping performed this week and there was absolutely no surprise in the first three to join the Top 12: Alexis Grace, Michael Sarver, Danny Gokey. The performances in the first batch were in general lackluster, and the only saving grace was a cameo from Michael Johns and Carly Smithson from the previous season (love them both). Big upset of the night was for Tatiana who was paired against Danny in the final elimination, and we all knew who was going to be chosen. I would, however, like to point out that there appears to be some stew brewing about Danny, and he may be losing popularity. Judge for yourself.

Second Group Results: Adam Lambert and Allison Iraheta were joined by Kris Allen in the next batch of kids to move into the Top 12. Adam is the goth-emo-esque looking rocker, and Allison is the red-haired 16 year old rocker. Kris Allen – I actually had a hard time remember who he was…come to think of it, I still don’t remember him. Anyway, Adam was awesome – I have loved him from the start, from the look to the vocals. Allison has an insane personality (and not in a good way), but an amazing rocker chick voice. Will she be this years Amanda Overmyer? She can’t drive a Harley, so we’ll see. Sad news of the night is that Nick/Norman isn’t going through. Wild card?

Third Group Results: Not too many surprises for group three. We’re going to have Lil Rounds who is a major diva in the making with a mega-voice, Scott MacIntyre the blind singer who is charming and a great pianist, and Jorge Nunez the contestant from PR who took vocal lessons to lose some of his accent. I’m not surprised by these and I’m happy that they made it into the Top 12. What I’m not happy about is Tatiana being put into the Wild Card round. Enough already.

Wildcard Week: Jasmine Murray was in first, and this wasn’t a big surprise. They have always thought she has great commercial potential and she showed that she’s got potential for big vocal songs too. Megan Joy Corkrey was in next, and the only thing I can say about her is that she dances like an absolute freak. Simon absolutely loves her. Number 12 was next and that was Matt Giraud, the soulful singer who does dueling pianos. He gave a great performance and deserved to be there…and then the shocker. They decided to make it a Top 13 and they put Anoop Desai through. I’m pretty happy about that because he’s a great singer.

So there you have it folks – American Idol has the Top 13 this year, and next week we’ll really see what they can do. Check out the results from the Top 13/12/11.

7 Responses to "American Idol 2009 – Building the Top 12"

1 | coffee

February 22nd, 2009 at 9:24 pm

Avatar

the producers of American Idol are obviously singling out Danny Gokey as their favorite, but i would like to see him win so i don’t mind

2 | heath

February 22nd, 2009 at 9:49 pm

Avatar

Yeah there has been a crazy amount of attention given to him, probably more than any other contestant this season…

I’m hoping that he does screw up a couple times so they can’t knock him a bit and make sure his ego doesn’t take over.

3 | Amanda

March 3rd, 2009 at 6:17 pm

Avatar

Okay, So all you haters of Adam, Go skrew yourselfs!!
Your just jealous! haha.
Its pretty funny actually.
Dont like the “Goth-emo-esque looking rocker”?
THEN STOP TALKING ABOUT IT!
Geez.

4 | Amanda

March 3rd, 2009 at 6:18 pm

Avatar

WAIT WAIT WAIT NO, I`d Like to delete that one..
but i dont know how…..
wow umm ya i feel dumb…
:/

5 | heath

March 3rd, 2009 at 8:08 pm

Avatar

Did you discover that I actually said very NICE things about Adam? :-)

6 | Colleen

March 7th, 2009 at 7:51 pm

Avatar

I just wanted you to know… we just watched the wildcard show… and our dvr cut off after they got rid of Tatiana (THANK GOD). It completely cut off before the final decisions were made. My husband now thinks I’m slightly insane as I gasped and then took off running to the computer muttering “Heath… Heath will tell us who the 12th is”

7 | heath

March 7th, 2009 at 8:33 pm

Avatar

And I not only told you who the Top 12 were, I told you who the Top 13 were!!! :-)
that was a HUGE surprise…..but a good surprise, I’m glad they put Anoop through.



  • heath: Oh Tommy...your comments mirror those of the Dawg as well. They thought Lee's voice was too big for the song. I don't think it was too big, but I can
  • Tommy Marx: Gotta disagree with you on this one sweetie. Yes, Crystal and Siobhan were definitely the best of the women, and while I didn't like the song he sang,
  • heath: Glad we're on the same page regarding Lee ;-). Otherwise, I'm really bored this year. I was hoping that we'd have another big personality like Adam L

About Heath L. Buckmaster

Fiction Author

IT Manager

Community Mgr.

Contact Heath
Buy the Book
Buy the Book

Sarcasm Central on Facebook